Friday, February 8, 2019

Vintage Colored Pencils: A. W. Faber “Castell” Polychromos (Contemporary Polychromos Comparison)

Vintage A.W. Faber Polychromos pencils

Faber-Castell Polychromos has long been my go-to for traditional (non-water-soluble) colored pencils. Harder than most artist-grade pencils, oil-based Polychromos has proven to be an excellent balance between softness (for easier application) and firmness (for crisp details) for most of my needs.

Both surprised and delighted to see a vintage set appear on eBay, I snapped it right up. I usually don’t buy large sets of vintage pencils, but I have never seen sets of any size of Polychromos, so the temptation was irresistible. I was also pleased because it gave me a rare opportunity to compare an old set with its contemporary counterpart. (Two others I’ve been able to compare in this way are Faber-Castell Goldfaber and Caran d’Ache Prismalo.)

Barely used at all, the set is missing only one pencil, and none was sharpened past production sharpening. (Photos show pencils after being freshly sharpened by me.) I was told by the eBay vendor that this set was used by her aunt in the early ‘60s. (I love it when the eBay vendor knows a product’s provenance! So often, vendors simply buy out estate sales and are clueless of a product’s age, and often I know more about the product than they do. But I always ask anyway, and occasionally the information provided is historically useful.) The pencils are in such beautiful condition that I think they spent most of their lives in their box.

The box, too, is in good condition, and opens to form an easel. Alas, its design is useless – the flap on top is too stiff to fold back, so it obstructs pencil removal. (I took all the pencils out, finally liberating them to live productive lives).

The box forms an easel. Unfortunately, the top flap makes the box unuseable.

Before I get further into this review, here’s a bit of visual history. Although this is the first set I’ve found, I’ve managed to acquire a few random single Polychromos pencils. Shown here are six A. W. Faber Polychromos (the bright green at the top is a contemporary one for comparison). Interestingly, the bottom one is made in the USA; all the rest are made in Germany, as is my contemporary set and the vintage set I’m reviewing. The old Polychromos have unfinished ends; contemporary ones have a rounded end cap with a gold band.
Top green pencil is contemporary; others are vintage.

Vintage pencils have plain, unfinished ends.

The vintage set I’m reviewing is probably not as old as those singles, based on the design, which is almost identical to my contemporary set: The round, glossy barrel is finished with a rounded end cap and a gold band.
Vintage Polychromos from the set I'm reviewing.

Branded A.W. Faber, the old pencils do not bear the “jousting knights” logo that appears on contemporary pencils – a logo that was adopted when the company began using the name Faber-Castell (according to Wikipedia).
From top: vintage Polychromos, newer vintage from the set reviewed here; contemporary with jousting knights and Faber-Castell name

In my exploration of vintage colored pencils, and especially when I’ve been able to compare older ones with contemporary ones of the same brand, I’ve almost always come to the same conclusion: Newer pencils are better, at least in terms of pigment quality – and as long as pencil manufacturing has remained in the company’s country. It’s only natural that as production technology improves and discoveries are made about pigments and binders, pencil quality would improve, too. So it was with some trepidation that I made swatches of the 71 colors: It would be heartbreaking if this lovely set were of inferior quality compared to the contemporary Polychromos pencils that I love!  

Much to my relief, they are of the same high quality; in fact, dare I say they are slightly superior? I picked out a few pencils that I could find matching color numbers for in my contemporary set to compare them one-to-one. Is it my imagination, or do the vintage pigments appear just a hair more vibrant? In application, they feel very slightly creamier. (Granted, if I were to mix all of them together and use them without looking at the branding, I would be hard-pressed to distinguish them, I’m sure; the differences are very subtle.)
Swatch comparison of same color numbers

Making the sketch of the garlic, satsuma and banana, the vintage pencils are every bit as good as their modern sisters. It’s always a pleasure to find a well-preserved specimen of colored pencil history that I can also enjoy using.

2/5/19 vintage Polychromos pencils in Stillman & Birn Zeta sketchbook

Nothing like a pile of colored pencils to warm a frigid day!


  1. i dont like the vintage dark sepia (175). It looks like a 4B pencil and it is not pigmented and creamy.

    1. Hmmm, that's interesting. Maybe the pigment has deteriorated over time. All of mine seem good as new.

  2. Tina,I have a full box of A W Faber Castell Polychromos.The box is purple with two labels,one of which is inside the box.The pencils say L&C HARDTMUTH "KOH-I-NOOR KOPIERSTIFT * 1561E.My aunt told me they were from the late 1930`s.Do you know anything about them.They are not sharpened.Tony

    1. Sounds like the pencils do not match the box. Koh-i-Noor copier pencils are entirely different from Polychromos colored pencils. I have a couple of those copier pencils, but I'm sure mine are not that old. Your set sounds if it's really from the '30s!

  3. I bought a fairly complete set of Polychromos pencils in the 1990s, they match the style reviewed here. At a glance they look similar to the modern pencils but the inscriptions on the side are bit different and they lack the 3-star light-fastness rating.

    Recently I compared my colors with the current range. There are quite a few new colors, all those with numbers above 200 (I bought a few!) Some are discontinued - light violet (139) and the greys from 195 - 198 have been replaced by new cool and warm grey series.

    Most of the colors still the same which is reassuring. Some colors were different. My scarlet red (118) is like yours, darker than the modern version. My cobalt blues (143 and 144) are also darker/denser than the current pencils. Curiously, I also have a set of Caran d'Ache Neocolor 1 crayons, also 20 years old, and their Cobalt blue has a similar shift.

  4. Hi, I have a set of the first Polychromos, with papers. And i want to sell, any idea for how much i can sell? I can't find on internet de se as mine.

    1. I'm sorry, I'm not an expert on pricing! My suggestion would be to search completed auctions on eBay and see if you can find similar sets. I do see these pop up occasionally on eBay, so you may see some. Good luck!

  5. Hi, Tina! Might you be familiar with the AW Faber "Castell" Color 9300? It looks to be colored pencils with a hexagonal barrel, lacquered to match lead color, and has a gold-dipped end. The logo on the pencil is the scale design.

    1. No, I don't think I've ever seen that one! Will look for it now! Thanks for the tip!

    2. Excited to hear what you find out about them. I've googled but the best results are only from ebay, and even then not much information either. I've emailed FC directly to ask about them. Hope they reply soon. :)


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...