 |
The three candidates for graphite wannabes (emulating the 6B-ish Blackwing extra soft graphite pencil) are, from top: Holbein, Derwent Lightfast and Caran d'Ache Luminance. |
When is a graphite pencil not? When it’s colored!
Among the many hidden talents of colored pencils is their ability to act like
graphite. Not completely, of course – graphite pencils will always have unique,
inimitable qualities. But colored pencils can be applied in pressure-sensitive,
subtly modulated layers just like graphite can – with far less smudging. In
addition, pigment has no reflective shine like graphite, which can sometimes
reduce the latter’s darkness even when the core is dark and soft.
A few weeks ago I started thinking about which colored pencils might make the best substitute for graphite. I wanted a pencil with
the softness of about a Japanese 6B (or a Blackwing “extra soft”), which is the
type I would use specifically for small, quick studies in which it’s important
to bang out dark values efficiently. In addition, the core would have to glide
as smoothly as possible, which facilitates speed, similar to the way soft
graphite flows.
The use described above is not typical for colored pencils,
which are generally applied slowly in multiple layers. In addition, Uglybooks
paper has more tooth than I might typically choose with soft pencils of any kind,
and my colored pencil choice might be different with a different paper. For the
purpose of making small studies, however, I am always using my daily-carry
Uglybook, so it’s important that the pencil I use pairs well with its paper.
With these criteria in mind, I auditioned six of my softest
colored pencils. It was just as interesting to see the ones that were eliminated
as it was to pick the finalists. For example, Prismacolor is easily one
of my favorite soft colored pencils for almost all uses, yet in this
application (or perhaps especially on this paper), Prismacolor feels “sticky”
and doesn’t glide easily the way graphite pencils do. Ideally, I wanted Carand’Ache Museum Aquarelle to serve as my graphite wannabe because a few are always
in my bag anyway, but it, too, “sticks” a bit. Worst of all was Derwent Inktense, which is also always in my bag, but it drags badly.
After eliminating all of those, my qualifying candidates were
the following: Holbein, Caran d’Ache Luminance and Derwent Lightfast.
 |
Holbein - nearly as smooth as graphite |
The first pencil I tried was Holbein, and right out
of the gate, I knew it was a strong contender. The other two had a tough act to
follow. After making several sketches with each pencil, Holbein is the winner
by a wide margin. In addition to being suitably soft and dark, it also glides
as smoothly as any soft colored pencil can on mildly toothy paper. It’s still not
quite as smooth as soft graphite, but surprisingly close. Interestingly,
Holbein has never been a pencil I reach for to make colored pencil drawings in
a more traditional manner, yet here it is my first choice as a graphite
wannabe! Will wonders never cease.
A distant second is Lightfast, which is also beautifully
soft but has more drag than Holbein.
Luminance, which I enjoy using on high-quality drawing paper,
is unpleasantly scratchy on Uglybook’s paper.
 |
Derwent Lightfast -- a distant second |
 |
Caran d'Ache Luminance -- scratchy |
These illuminating and surprising results further justify
why it is necessary to have a wide range of colored pencils for the task at
hand, even if the task is to pretend it’s graphite.